Is It Better to Grow Microgreens in Soil or Water? Cultivation Comparison

HomeGrowingIs It Better to Grow Microgreens in Soil or Water? Cultivation Comparison

When it comes to growing microgreens, both soil and water cultivation methods have their advantages. Soil-grown microgreens often develop a more robust flavor due to the wider range of nutrients available in the soil. Water-based hydroponic systems, on the other hand, offer faster growth rates and a more controlled environment. Ultimately, the choice between soil or water cultivation for microgreens depends on your specific preferences, space availability, and desired outcomes.

Advantages of Growing Microgreens in Soil

You may be wondering why it’s preferable to grow microgreens in soil rather than water. Growing microgreens in soil has several advantages.

Firstly, soil provides nutrients that are essential for healthy plant growth, and the plants can absorb these minerals more efficiently than when grown in water alone.

Secondly, keeping the plants in soil helps protect them from certain diseases that thrive in wet conditions.

Therefore, growing microgreens in soil is often a better choice than hydroponics or aquaponics systems.

Nutrient Absorption

Soil-grown microgreens can absorb more nutrients, providing a fuller taste and vibrant color that you won’t get from water-grown ones. This is because the soil has better texture and pH balance for the roots of the microgreens to draw out essential minerals and vitamins. The increased nutrient absorption in soil results in higher nutritional value, including vitamin C, iron, magnesium, calcium, and other trace elements compared to hydroponically grown greens.

Furthermore, soil also contains beneficial microbes that act as natural fertilizers by breaking down organic matter to release vital nutrients required for optimal growth of microgreens. Growing in soil helps keep these microbes alive, which further enhances the flavor and quality of your microgreens.

Disease Resistance

By growing in soil, microgreens can naturally fight off disease and provide a more robust flavor. Soil offers many advantages when it comes to disease resistance for microgreens, such as improved drainage which helps minimize standing water and reduces the likelihood of fungal infections. The addition of organic matter to the soil can help increase beneficial microbial activity that prevents diseases from taking hold. The introduction of pest control measures such as crop rotation or companion planting can reduce the chance of pests introducing diseases into your crop.

RELATED:  Growing Microgreens on Felt: Exploring a Unique Growing Medium

Growing in soil also provides a natural defense against disease-causing organisms because it contains nutrients that support healthy plant growth and discourage pathogens from taking hold. Additionally, since microgreens are harvested so early on in their life cycle, they don’t need to be exposed to harsh chemical treatments often used for traditional crops grown in water systems, making them much better suited to resisting disease naturally through soil-based growing methods.

Advantages of Growing Microgreens in Water

Growing microgreens in water has its advantages. It’s easier to monitor the water levels since you don’t need to worry about soil consistency or drainage. Additionally, microgreens grown in water can have faster growth rates due to increased oxygen availability and quick access to nutrients from the solution. Furthermore, there is less risk of disease or pests when growing in water compared with soil-based systems.

Easier to Monitor Water Levels

Monitoring moisture levels is much simpler when growing microgreens in water, making it easy to ensure your plants are thriving. By using automation systems, such as hydroponic systems, you can have more control over the amount of water provided to your microgreens. This helps to reduce runoff and prevent overwatering.

Additionally, when using a hydroponic or aquaponic system, it will be easier to monitor and adjust the pH level of the water as necessary. This precision allows for greater nurturing of your microgreens and can help them reach their full potential.

Furthermore, automation systems provide better aeration for your plants, which helps with growth and development.

Faster Growth Rates

Growing microgreens in water instead of soil can dramatically speed up their growth rates, allowing you to enjoy healthy crops in a fraction of the time. Water provides an ideal environment for plants to absorb nutrients and carbon dioxide quickly, which contributes to faster growth than soil-based methods.

Here are three key benefits of growing microgreens in water:

  1. You can harvest your crop quicker – growing them in water reduces the total time needed for germination and maturation to just 7-14 days in comparison with 14-21 days when grown in soil.
  2. You can maximize nutrient absorption – hydroponic techniques ensure that the plant roots have easy access to essential nutrients, enabling maximum absorption into the plants for faster development.
  3. You don’t need to worry about soil nutrition – since water is used as a medium for delivering nutrients, you don’t need to spend extra time or money on fertilizers or additives for soil nutrition purposes.
RELATED:  Red Sorrel Microgreens: Tangy and Refreshing Leaves

All these factors make it easier and more effective to grow healthy microgreens at a much faster rate when compared with traditional harvesting techniques using soil.

Challenges of Growing Microgreens in Soil

Managing soil for growing microgreens is a herculean task, requiring near-constant attention and seemingly infinite effort! The most difficult part of growing microgreens in soil is the potential for nutrient deficiencies and soil contamination.

Nutrient deficiencies can occur if the soil is not amended correctly with fertilizers as it needs to provide essential nutrients to the plants. If there is any imbalance in these essential nutrients, this can lead to stunted growth or even death of the plants.

Soil contamination can also be an issue if pesticides or other hazardous materials have been used on the soil prior to planting. This could potentially contaminate your crops and make them unsafe for consumption.

In order to ensure healthy growth of your microgreens, it’s important that you regularly test the levels of essential nutrients in your soil and adjust accordingly as needed. Additionally, you should avoid using potentially harmful chemicals on your soil as they may have adverse effects on both plant health and human health when consumed.

It’s also important that you take precautions against pests and other critters which may try to feed on your crops while they are still young and vulnerable. Proper pest control measures must be taken in order for successful cultivation of microgreens in soil.

Finally, watering your microgreens correctly will also play a significant role in their success when grown in soil. Too much water can cause anaerobic conditions where oxygen cannot reach down into the roots, leading to poor development of root systems which ultimately affects plant health overall; too little water will prevent sufficient uptake of nutrients from the soils which again has an effect on plant health overall. Therefore, it’s important that you monitor moisture levels closely while providing just enough water at regular intervals so that none gets wasted due to evaporation or overflow caused by heavy rainfalls or flooding scenarios.

Overall, managing the environment around your microgreens when grown in soil requires extra attention compared to when grown hydroponically, but with proper care, they can thrive just as well! It’s up to you how often you check nutrient levels, apply fertilizers/pesticides or water them, but doing so regularly will help keep them healthy over time and enable better absorption of nutrients from their environment, thus ensuring greater yields come harvest time!

RELATED:  Best Microgreens Mat: Creating a Perfect Growing Surface

Challenges of Growing Microgreens in Water

Now that you have a better understanding of the challenges of growing microgreens in soil, let’s take a look at how these same challenges can affect microgreens grown in water. When it comes to growing microgreens in water, there are four main issues to consider: pest control, oxygen levels, nutrient availability, and pH balance.

First, pest control is more difficult when you’re growing microgreens in water than soil. This is because pests, such as aphids or fungus gnats, may be able to survive in the standing water for longer periods of time and cause damage to the plants. Additionally, since the roots don’t have access to dirt or other natural predators like they would when planted in soil, they’re more vulnerable to attack from pests.

Second, oxygen levels can be problematic with this method as well. Microgreens require oxygen for proper growth and development, but if there isn’t enough present, then the roots will suffer from a lack of nutrients needed for healthy growth. Furthermore, if there’s too much oxygen present, then it can cause root rot, which could lead to the death of the plant.

Third is nutrient availability. While some nutrients may be available from your water source, those will likely not be enough for optimal growth and health of your crops, so fertilizers must be added regularly throughout the process. Lastly, you also need to keep an eye on pH levels as this will impact how well your plants absorb nutrients from their environment.

Knowing all this information about growing microgreens in water should help you make an informed decision on whether or not this method is right for you and your specific needs – but ultimately soil remains preferable due to its ability to provide better nutrient absorption and lower risk of disease spread among plants.

Kathy Turner
Kathy Turner
Kathy Turner is the founder of, a popular blog dedicated to helping people become master microgreen growers. Kathy is passionate about helping others learn how to grow the healthiest, most nutrient-rich microgreens. She believes that with the right knowledge and resources, anyone can become a successful microgreen grower. Learn more about Kathy by viewing her full Author Profile.

Popular posts

My favorites

I'm social